Muldoon Pizza

Reviews

• Linda M.

  star star star star star 23 May 2026

  My favorite pizza and salad place. I order the huge antipasto  salad with my flavir if dressing. It takes me 4 meals to finish it. They use plenty of cheese in their pizzas, and i live the not soggy crust.

• Terry M.

  star star star star_border star_border 22 May 2026

  First time I tried this place it wasn't bad but a bit lacking in flavor. The restaurant seems to be nice I just picked up an order rather than dining in. Everyone seemed very friendly.

• Shelton D.

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 22 May 2026

  Just went to Muldoon Pizza for the first time. After seeing the ads and reading the reviews, I knew it was going to be a great dinner. We ordered an appetizer of meatballs with sauce and the 16 inch House Special. As soon as the waitress walked away from taking our order, my wife sees something inside the Parmesan cheese shaker. Inside the shaker, running circles, was a 3/4 inch long cockroach! A freaking COCKROACH!! Living in the Parmesan cheese shaker! Needless to say, we didn't stick around for dinner. This happened 20 minutes ago, and I'm still totally repulsed. If the cheese on the table is infested, just imagine what the kitchen looks like. Never again

• Aaron F.

  star star star star star 19 May 2026

  This is our go-to place for pizza. We love the retro atmosphere and the service is pretty great. We love places like the Moose's Tooth, but there's usually way too many people and you might have to wait a while to get seated. We usually go once a week now and are never disappointed. It's what you might think of when you imagine a small, local neighborhood pizzeria. We normally get the pepperoni pizza. If a place can make the basic pizza taste amazing, then that's a win in my book. If a place can't even get pepperoni right, then it's not a good pizza place. These folks get it right every time.

• Christy S.

  star star star star star 17 May 2026

  Muldoon pizza is conveniently located in well, Muldoon of course!  The restaurant is spacious, clean, and I quickly discovered my booth seating was comfortable.  The waitress, Michelle was super friendly, attentive and very likable.  She promptly lit a candle, provided menus and got our drink order.  The salad was a mountain of quality toppings, enough for two people to share.  My half pepperoni / half cheese pizza was Very good!  The crust was perfect to my liking; not too thick and not too thin.  Once again, I noted the toppings were abundantly provided....my growling stomach shouted a big "thank you!"
  Ample parking available in front and side of the restaurant.